A certification body is selecting the audit team for a logistics company's stage 2 audit. One proposed auditor worked as the company's ISMS consultant, helping to write its risk assessment methodology, until 14 months ago. The company says it is comfortable with her joining the team. What should the certification body decide?
the answer and reasoning
Correct answerB. Exclude her from this audit, because ISO/IEC 17021-1 bars personnel who gave the client consultancy within the past two years.
ISO/IEC 17021-1 does not allow a certification body to use personnel in audit or other certification activities for a client to which they provided management system consultancy within two years of the end of that consultancy. Fourteen months is inside that period. Limiting her to other areas still leaves the self-review threat to the whole audit, and the client's consent cannot remove a restriction placed on the certification body.
Why the other options fail
- A. The restriction applies to her participation in the audit as a whole, not only to the areas she designed, because the self-review threat affects the team's conclusions.
- C. Impartiality obligations sit with the certification body; a client's acceptance does not lift the two-year restriction on former consultants.
Published exam-scope sources: ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 management system certification requirements · EA clarification on certification personnel and previous consultancy · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor training course page
