Aegentra Labs

Free, no account required

ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor practice questions

Question 1 tests auditor impartiality. Questions 2–5 follow a stage 2 audit of a gym chain: internal audit objectivity, test data, sampling change records and the closing meeting. Reveal each answer to see the reasoning and why the other options fail.

These practice questions are independently authored by Harry Sidhu and Aegentra and are not official PECB examination materials. They do not reproduce confidential or recalled PECB examination content. Read the methodology.

Questions
5
Options
3 each
Answers
Explained
Start question 1

Independent subject review and learner calibration are pending. Explanations retain the cited ISO 19011:2018 and ISO/IEC 27000:2018 editions. ISO has published 2026 editions; alignment with the current PECB course materials has not yet been verified.

What this exact sample covers

Auditing an ISMS at stage 2

  • Impartiality and objectivity
  • Annex A findings
  • Sampling and audit conclusions
  1. Question 01Domain 4 · application

    A certification body is selecting the audit team for a logistics company's stage 2 audit. One proposed auditor worked as the company's ISMS consultant, helping to write its risk assessment methodology, until 14 months ago. The company says it is comfortable with her joining the team. What should the certification body decide?

    1. AAssign her to the team but not to the risk methodology, because impartiality is achieved when auditors do not audit their own work.
    2. BExclude her from this audit, because ISO/IEC 17021-1 bars personnel who gave the client consultancy within the past two years.
    3. CAssign her to the team once the company signs a declaration accepting the potential conflict of interest in writing.
    the answer and reasoning

    Correct answerB. Exclude her from this audit, because ISO/IEC 17021-1 bars personnel who gave the client consultancy within the past two years.

    ISO/IEC 17021-1 does not allow a certification body to use personnel in audit or other certification activities for a client to which they provided management system consultancy within two years of the end of that consultancy. Fourteen months is inside that period. Limiting her to other areas still leaves the self-review threat to the whole audit, and the client's consent cannot remove a restriction placed on the certification body.

    Why the other options fail

    • A. The restriction applies to her participation in the audit as a whole, not only to the areas she designed, because the self-review threat affects the team's conclusions.
    • C. Impartiality obligations sit with the certification body; a client's acceptance does not lift the two-year restriction on former consultants.

    Published exam-scope sources: ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 management system certification requirements · EA clarification on certification personnel and previous consultancy · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor training course page

  2. Scenario for questions 2–5

    Stage 2 at a gym chain with a busy app

    Tolverne Fitness operates 31 gyms and a membership app used by about 84,000 members to book classes, store health questionnaires and manage direct-debit payments. Its information security management system (ISMS) under ISO/IEC 27001:2022 covers the app, the member database and head-office IT, with about 610 staff in scope. You are the audit team leader for the certification body conducting Tolverne's three-day stage 2 audit.

    Tolverne completed its internal audit programme in May. An external contractor audited clauses 4 to 10 and most Annex A controls. The audit of access management and backup, both operated by the IT team, was performed by the IT manager, who leads that team and holds a lead auditor training certificate. On day 1, an auditor finds that the app's test environment, hosted separately from production with its own access controls, holds a full copy of the live member database, including health questionnaires and bank account details. The copy is refreshed weekly so that developers and an external testing contractor can reproduce reported faults.

    The app change log shows 140 changes deployed to production in the last six months, 11 of them recorded as emergency changes. When the auditor asks for change records, the development lead offers five changes that he says 'show the process at its best', with approvals and test evidence already gathered in a folder. At the closing meeting on day 3, Tolverne's managing director asks the audit team leader to confirm, before the team leaves, that the certificate will be issued, so that marketing can announce it the following week.

    Question 02Domain 5 · analysis

    The audit team is evaluating Tolverne's internal audit programme. Should a nonconformity be raised against clause 9.2 of ISO/IEC 27001:2022?

    1. ANo, because clause 9.2.2 lets the organization choose its internal auditors, and the IT manager holds a lead auditor training certificate.
    2. BYes, because clause 9.2.2 requires internal audits to be carried out by an external party that is independent of the organization.
    3. CYes, because clause 9.2.2 c) requires auditors to be selected to ensure objectivity and impartiality, and the IT manager audited her own team.
    the answer and reasoning

    Correct answerC. Yes, because clause 9.2.2 c) requires auditors to be selected to ensure objectivity and impartiality, and the IT manager audited her own team.

    Clause 9.2.2 c) requires the organization to select auditors and conduct audits so as to ensure objectivity and the impartiality of the audit process. The IT manager audited access management and backup, which her own team operates, so impartiality was not ensured for that part of the programme. Competence does not cure this, and the standard does not require external auditors.

    Why the other options fail

    • A. A lead auditor certificate shows competence, which is a separate matter from impartiality; she still audited processes she is responsible for.
    • B. Internal auditors can be employees; clause 9.2.2 requires objectivity and impartiality, not independence from the whole organization.

    Published exam-scope sources: ISO/IEC 27001:2022 information security management systems · ISO 19011:2018 auditing guidelines — cited edition · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor training course page

  3. Question 03Domain 2 · analysis

    Against which Annex A control of ISO/IEC 27001:2022 should the audit team most directly record the test environment finding?

    1. AA.8.31 separation of development, test and production environments, since production data is present in the test environment.
    2. BA.8.33 test information, since the full live database is copied for testing rather than being selected and protected for that use.
    3. CA.8.25 secure development life cycle, since reproducing reported faults is part of how the membership app is developed and maintained.
    the answer and reasoning

    Correct answerB. A.8.33 test information, since the full live database is copied for testing rather than being selected and protected for that use.

    Under A.8.33 the organization chooses what goes into a test environment and how that data is protected. Copying the whole live database, health questionnaires and bank details included, so that developers and a contractor can reproduce faults is a failure in how test data is chosen and protected. The environments are already separated with their own access controls, and the development life cycle is too broad to describe this specific failure.

    Why the other options fail

    • A. The test environment is hosted separately with its own access controls, which is what A.8.31 addresses; the problem is the data placed in it.
    • C. A.8.25 sets rules for secure development in general; the evidence points to a specific failure in what data is used for testing and how it is safeguarded.

    Published exam-scope sources: ISO/IEC 27001:2022 information security management systems · ISO/IEC 27002:2022 information security controls · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor training course page

  4. Question 04Domain 5 · application

    How should the auditor respond to the development lead's offer of five change records?

    1. AAccept the five records, because the development lead knows which changes are typical and the prepared folder saves audit time.
    2. BRequest all 140 change records, because a certification audit must examine each record when the population is under 200.
    3. CSelect the sample from the full change log, including emergency changes, so that the auditor chooses the records.
    the answer and reasoning

    Correct answerC. Select the sample from the full change log, including emergency changes, so that the auditor chooses the records.

    ISO 19011 guidance on audit sampling expects the auditor to define and select the sample so that it is representative and the conclusions are reliable. Records chosen by the auditee because they 'show the process at its best' are biased. Sampling from the whole log, with the emergency changes deliberately included, tests how the process really works. No rule requires every record to be examined below a population size.

    Why the other options fail

    • A. An auditee-selected sample of best cases is biased and cannot support a reliable conclusion about the change process as a whole.
    • B. There is no population threshold that requires 100% checking; sampling is normal in certification audits when it is planned and justified.

    Published exam-scope sources: ISO 19011:2018 auditing guidelines — cited edition · ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 management system certification requirements · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor training course page

  5. Question 05Domain 6 · application

    How should the audit team leader respond to the managing director's request at the closing meeting?

    1. AExplain that the audit team recommends and the certification body decides after an independent review.
    2. BConfirm that the certificate will be issued, because the audit team leader may grant certification once stage 2 is complete.
    3. CConfirm that the certificate will be issued once the managing director signs the closing meeting record accepting the findings.
    the answer and reasoning

    Correct answerA. Explain that the audit team recommends and the certification body decides after an independent review.

    Under ISO/IEC 17021-1, the certification decision is taken by the certification body, by persons who were not involved in the audit, after reviewing the audit report, the findings and any corrective action plans. The audit team leader presents the findings and the recommendation but cannot confirm the outcome. Signing the closing meeting record acknowledges the findings; it does not grant certification.

    Why the other options fail

    • B. The audit team leader has no authority to grant certification; the decision rests with the certification body after independent review.
    • C. The closing meeting record acknowledges the findings presented; certification still depends on the certification body's decision.

    Published exam-scope sources: ISO/IEC 17021-1:2015 management system certification requirements · ISO/IEC 27006-1:2024 ISMS certification body requirements · ISO/IEC 27001 Lead Auditor training course page

Preparing for a different exam?

Every live exam has its own five free questions, written for that exam's domains.